August 16, 2022





The Game also calls out Eminem’s racial insecurities as a white man contributing to a Black artform. “One thing you can never have is my motherf**kin' Black, skin… / He got all the Blackest friends / He wants to be African," The Game raps before slamming Em's street credibility outside of hip-hop and calling out his inability to be respected like other rappers are. “To see that I was in the white Rolls Royce with five .9's/ When you was pretendin' to be the white Royce da 5'9."
He adds, “I never heard you in a club, I never heard you in a bar/ Eleven albums and ten never got played inside of my car/ I'd rather listen to Snitch9ine like sixty-nine times/ And participate in sixty-nines with sixty-nine nuns than listen to you/ You're a Karen, call the cops, tell 'em it's a Black man on your block.”
The Game continues to raise questions surrounding Eminem's integrity as a white rapper, specifically when the Detroit rapper had a “durag for ten years and never had one wave" -- a reference to Em's tone-deaf attempt at showing solidarity for the Black community while appropriating the culture. At the end of the day, The Game echoes the criticism that many have expressed towards Em over the years. "He’s an appropriator, he’s washed up, he’s never been respected like other rappers, his music isn’t as good now," and so on.
What makes all these disses feel fresh is The Game’s clear hunger and penmanship on display. He sharpens his knives heavily on this track, and it makes for one of the most believable and well-crafted attempted takedowns of Eminem’s career from a purely lyrical stance. There’s also a line surrounding Eminem's appearance on 60 Minutes where he rebukes that “nothing rhymes with orange." It might be a big cultural moment for Eminem and one that his fans love, but it’s also easy to clown for its pretentiousness and lyrical nerdiness.
One of The Game’s most scathing moments on the record is his assessment of Eminem's lack of contribution to the culture, despite his popularity. “Twenty-three years, still ain't penetratin' the culture/ You are not, top five, in mine, B.I.G or 'Pac eyes/ No André, no Nas, stop tellin' white lie / Sniff a white line, this the right time/ I Suge Knight Vanilla Ice, I'm not Mr. Nice Guy," The Game scoffs.
The Game’s most cutting and brutal disses on this track are mostly those relating to Eminem's personal life including his past struggles with pill addiction. “You depressed, you just maskin' it/ You pop a Adderall, a Vicodin, and a Aspirin/ But the math wasn't mathin' in.” There’s also a bizarre reference to a conspiracy connecting Eminem to the Jeffrey Epstein case, although this has been debunked. Nevertheless, The Game uses Eminem’s trademark high-pitched delivery to depict him being chased by Epstein around his island.
There’s also one element to almost any diss record towards Eminem that historically becomes the most controversial: referencing his daughter, Hailie. “Dear Slim, Hailie's with me and she's unharmed for now,” he raps, with the ad-lib, “Dad, I’m really scared,” following soon after. It may be a vague parody of songs like “My Dad's Gone Crazy" and "Stan" but let’s not forget that Eminem’s beef with Machine Gun Kelly was triggered over comments about Hailie, as well. While The Game really went for it on this track, it’s also not as wild or explosive as it could’ve been. However, it’s still a thin line to walk.
There song also contains nods to Eminem's family-oriented tracks, (“You love your mother?/ Well, I'm cleanin' out your closet for you and your half-brother”) along with more references to the home life depicted in 8 Mile. In addition, The Game brings Eminem's absentee father into the fold. “Now I'm here, hope you ready/ This is not mom's spaghetti/ This your dad was twenty-two when he ate lil' Debbie." Not only does The Game name-drop Eminem’s mother, but he takes the diss all the way back to when his parents started their relationship. “'Cause she was only fifteen, so how could one not sympathize with her havin' you as a teen?/ She had to lose herself in the moment, give up her dreams/ Just to see her son out here lookin' like a wigger in jeans.”
In the final verse, The Game delivers even more fiery shots that are written to stick in Em’s head long after the track ends. “Little Marshall Mathers/ Mad 'cause nobody thinks that little Marshall matters.” There are also plenty of shots that condemn Eminem’s personality and talent. “God made you damn near perfect, he just missed your soul/ You ain't the shell of who you used to be," The Game says.
To cap the whole song off, save for a taunting outro, The Game delivers a sharp closing line as the kill shot. “Your fans want a rap god, well, fuck it, I'ma give 'em one/ I came to put Slim in a box but he already live in one," he raps. It’s a final nail in the coffin after an arsenal of attacks against Eminem’s music, life, and career.
Now we get to the most important question: did Eminem get bodied by The Game on this track? Are we going to see a response? Can Eminem beat The Game here?
As entertaining as the diss may be, this is Eminem we’re talking about here. The highest-selling rapper of all time is still adored by millions of fans and his release schedule hasn’t slowed down, either. Whether or not he’s getting the same praise as he once did is up for debate but it’s unrealistic to expect his career to fizzle out as a result of any one diss track.
The Game is no slouch, though. His status in the rap game means that this is more of a legitimate challenge to Eminem with higher stakes involved. Maybe Eminem will respond for the culture. Or perhaps, they’ll engage in a purely lyrical competition rather than messy personal attacks that can define rap beef these days.
But is this a big hit to Eminem’s career? If anything, it’s gotten him more attention and streams. Whoever's championing “The Black Slim Shady” probably wasn’t listening to much Eminem, to begin with. Eminem’s longevity is imprinted in the culture. The charts, sales records, and mainstream audiences have only reinforced it. One diss track won’t change that.
With all that being said, The Game holds his own with a skillfully executed diss record through sharp lyricism and homages to Eminem’s catalog. Even if you’re a Slim Shady stan, you can still acknowledge how The Game delivered plenty of stand-out moments to captivate his audience for 10 minutes.
Compared to some of the most notable feuds in hip-hop history -- Biggie and Tupac, Jay-Z and Nas, and even contemporary beef like Pusha T and Drake, -- this rivalry may not be the most personal, nor is “The Black Slim Shady” the destructive career-shifting diss track that it could’ve been. At face value, this is a West Coast giant going up against someone who he shares a lot of history with, and someone who is heralded as one of the greatest rappers of all time. If Eminem responds to The Game, this might make for a legendary sparring match of lyricism, legacy, and ludicrous flows. There’s not a lot of personal conflicts to unpack: just two titans of their field recognizing their history and duking it out for the culture.